So far, I am happy with having chosen this product. I ordered both the mint and the unscented. I am using the unscented first. I like the feel of the product on my lips. I am still getting used to the applicator. It seems that I can keep it from receding back into the tube if I squeeze the tube while I apply. I love the fact that this product comes in a cardboard tube. So, I am willing to work on my application technique to avoid sending more little plastic waste objects into the sea.